Dr Jens Behnke answers questions from Dr Noémi Radványi, from Hungary, for www.homeopatika. blog.hu/, about the new evidence for homeopathy, research methodology and interpretation of data from clinical trials.
Dr N Radványi: There are many trials that measure the effectiveness of homeopathy. Some of them observe no difference between homeopathy and placebo [dummy pill], and many of them prove that homeopathy is an effective therapy. What research is valid? How is it possible to come to such different conclusions?
Dr Behnke: Different studies for different questions
First of all you have to distinguish between ‘effectiveness’ and ‘efficacy.’ The effectiveness of any intervention is measured in outcome studies under real life circumstances. Concerning homeopathy this means that you try to evaluate the effects of potentised remedies plus anamnesis [a patient’s account of their medical history], expectations of the patient, probable therapeutic suggestions and other context factors. Efficacy in contrast means the pure specific effects of potentised remedies without all these additional variables. Therefore, efficacy is measured in randomised, placebo-controlled, double-blind trials [RCTs] where all these possible confounding factors are ruled out by the study design.
THE EFFICACY PARADOX
Outcome studies provide answers to the question ‘What helps the patient in clinical practice?’ whereas RCTs give information about the causal relationship between a therapeutic effect and a substance. This is not the same, because some interventions might exhibit large specific effects, but they may prove to be not as useful in routine care as other treatments that show smaller specific effects in RCTs. This difference forms the so-called ‘Efficacy Paradox.’ Because of this paradox it has proven useful to evaluate medical interventions in different types of studies. A multi-perspective view highlights more particular features of interventions, enabling more detailed answers to heterogenous questions.
This story is from the February 2018 edition of Homeopathy & You.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the February 2018 edition of Homeopathy & You.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Homeopathic Practice & The Power Of Objective Assessment
The best thing for homeopathic students and also doctors to do is to go back to the essence, or ‘source,’ of Dr Samuel Hahnemann’s tenets, and use the power of objective observation to revolutionise their homeopathic skills and practice of medicine, in the best manner possible — simply, sensibly, and without rigmarole.
Multiple Sclerosis & Homeopathy
Homeopathy does not treat just multiple sclerosis symptoms per se, but rather the person having such symptoms with all their nuanced temperamental aspects, likes and dislikes, aside from complex personal and family history. This purports to deftly taking the full case and understanding the totality of symptoms in the context of the patient’s overall experience of life, and finding specific homeopathic remedies for the disorder.
Homeopathy For Illness-Free Vacations
The holiday season is upon us — where has the old year gone? During the last month-and-a-half, many of us have been gearing up for a busy few weeks. But, don’t let self-care fall by the wayside. Who has the time to get sick during the busiest time of the New Year? So, keep the following tips, along with select homeopathic remedies, in mind this holiday season — and, your body and mind will thank you for it.
No More ‘Sit Bone' Pain
Elise is sixty. As she sits in the chair opposite me I get the sense that she is tensed and anxious. This lady was careful to put down a buttock support in the chair but was struggling to find just the right angle for sitting in it.
Wheeze Relief With Holistic Homeopathy
Homeopathy treats asthmatic symptoms that are unique to the individual, not just the outward signs — because, no two asthmatic individuals present with the same symptoms.
Gelsemium Effects ‘In Vitro:'
A bridge between homeopathy & molecular biology.
Tamannaah's Wellness Mantra
Tamannaah Bhatia is known for her gorgeous looks, great figure and long, dark tresses.
A Case Of Profound Depression
A Case Of Profound Depression
The Bug Paradox & Homeopathy
The wheel has turned full circle — in spite of advances in conventional medicine. Call it the growing paradox of flu and other viral illnesses, or what you may. Homeopathy has a lot to offer, in the prevention and treatment of such illnesses — without the fear of ‘drug-resistance.’
Homeopathy In Breast Cancer Surgery: The First Randomised Clinical Trial On Treatment With Arnica Montana
Homeopathy In Breast Cancer Surgery: The First Randomised Clinical Trial On Treatment With Arnica Montana
