The Rescue of Portland's FIREHOUSE 17
Old House Journal|November - December 2021
IN WHAT BECAME THE PROJECT OF A LIFETIME, THE REHABILITATION OF A 1912 FIREHOUSE IS ADAPTIVE REUSE WITH HEART AND SOUL. DECOMMISSIONED IN 1968, ALLOWED TO DETERIORATE AND LATER REMODELED, THE OLD FIREHOUSE HAD BEEN BUILT DURING THE DAYS OF HORSE-DRAWN ENGINES. THE PROJECT WAS SPEARHEADED BY RESTORAT ION CONSULTANT KARLA PEARLSTEIN, IN PORTLAND, OREGON. SHE NOW CALLS THE FIREHOUSE HOME.
DONNA PIZZI
The Rescue of Portland's FIREHOUSE 17

It took a devoted team to rehabilitate and restore Portland’s Firehouse 17. Previously remodeled as a residence in the 1980s, the building had been stripped of much original material, and other elements covered over. A few years ago, it was slated to become four separate units, which would further degrade its history. Karla Pearlstein, a serial restorer and preservation consultant, stepped up, albeit with some reluctance. She was buoyed by collaborator Matthew Roman, a designer, who calls this restoration “one of the preeminent projects of my career.” Roman recruited Patrick O’Neill, of Greenline Fine Woodworking, to be general contractor. The project ultimately would win the DeMuro Award for Excellence in Preservation, Reuse, and Community Revitalization.

Firehouse Engine Company 17 was designed by then-Battalion Chief Lee Gray Holden, designer of 24 Portland firehouses and Fire Bureau Chief from 1923 to 1927. Built in 1912, this one featured dual bays to accommodate a horse-drawn steam pumper and ladder truck. Five horses were stabled on the ground floor, and six to eight firemen slept in the second-floor bunkroom. The firehouse was motorized in the 1920s, decommissioned by 1968; used only as a storage warehouse, it fell into disrepair. In 1984, the previous owner adapted it for a private residence. Meeting code requirements proved more important than aesthetics. He enclosed the staircase, demolished the recessed bay, and removed original windows. Modern “parquet floors” were installed over the original fir. Oddly inappropriate Palladian windows and contemporary stair rails were added. Pearlstein would discover fir wainscoting obscured when a handball court was added in the Day Room.

This story is from the November - December 2021 edition of Old House Journal.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the November - December 2021 edition of Old House Journal.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM OLD HOUSE JOURNALView All
faded luxe IN A RETURN TO SAVANNAH
Old House Journal

faded luxe IN A RETURN TO SAVANNAH

Residents of the Blue Ridge Mountains find their city home in a converted commercial building in beautiful Savannah, Georgia.

time-read
2 mins  |
January - February 2025
a hudson valley VERNACULAR
Old House Journal

a hudson valley VERNACULAR

When Harlan Bratcher started looking for a country house in New York, in 1990, he knew what he wanted-something peaceful and serene, an escape from the hectic lifestyle of Manhattan.

time-read
3 mins  |
January - February 2025
the Dr. Mills house RESTORED
Old House Journal

the Dr. Mills house RESTORED

In rural Washington State, a dedicated couple bring back a 1912 bungalow that once had been the town's hospital.

time-read
3 mins  |
January - February 2025
The Right Masonry Tool for Repointing
Old House Journal

The Right Masonry Tool for Repointing

The mortar between individual bricks or stones begins to erode after many years. That might be attributed to rain and wind, leaky gutters, building settlement, or such chemical agents as de-icing salts.

time-read
1 min  |
January - February 2025
How To Remove Wallpaper
Old House Journal

How To Remove Wallpaper

There's more than one way to do it; try them all until you find what works for your situation.

time-read
5 mins  |
January - February 2025
living with PLASTICS anxiety
Old House Journal

living with PLASTICS anxiety

Plastics are ubiquitous in modern life. Even houses built long before vinyl caught on are now full of polymer-based products, from the hoses in pull-down faucets to plastic light switches. Now that we know exposure to certain plastics can be hazardous to human health, we need guidance on how to evaluate building products for potential impacts.

time-read
3 mins  |
January - February 2025
homey Craftsman Textiles today
Old House Journal

homey Craftsman Textiles today

For bungalows, Craftsman houses, and Tudors that might have rather severe woodwork and furniture, textiles are a critical part of the decorative scheme.

time-read
2 mins  |
January - February 2025
Navigating the Lumberyard - Here's some lumber lingo you should know before you venture into a lumberyard.
Old House Journal

Navigating the Lumberyard - Here's some lumber lingo you should know before you venture into a lumberyard.

Here's some lumber lingo you should know before you venture into a lumberyard. Almost everyone fixing an old house will end up at a lumberyard-whether it's a local supplier or the organized aisles of a big-box home-improvement store.

time-read
5 mins  |
September - October 2024
a farmhouse renewed
Old House Journal

a farmhouse renewed

Sensitive renovations and restoration work preserved a house that dates to 1799.

time-read
3 mins  |
September - October 2024
AN OVERVIEW OF METAL ROOFING
Old House Journal

AN OVERVIEW OF METAL ROOFING

METAL ROOFS ARE RESURGENT, FOR GOOD REASONS.

time-read
1 min  |
September - October 2024