There was never any way Kieran Read’s record as captain would stand comparison with the man he replaced in the job.
His predecessor, Richie McCaw, will probably never be surpassed in terms of longevity and success. His 10 years as All Blacks captain saw him lead the team more than 100 times and win the World Cup twice.
There was that and six Rugby Championships, three World Player of the year awards and a win ratio of close to 90 per cent.
So it was never going to be fair to compare and contrast the respective captaincy periods of McCaw and Read and make comparisons based purely on the statistics.
Read actually posted numbers that would stand impressively against any other captain. Just not McCaw. He captained the team 52 times which is one more than Sean Fitzpatrick managed.
Under Read’s leadership, the All Blacks won 85 per cent of their tests, retained the Bledisloe Cup and won the Rugby Championship three times out of four.
The failure to win the World Cup will forever upset Read and forever count against him when he knocks on the door of the Pantheon looking to take a place among the greats.
But to see his career in numbers only is to miss the essence of what he brought to the role and what he did for the All Blacks. It was no surprise to hear Sonny Bill Williams sign off his All Blacks career by saying Read was the best captain he ever played under.
Williams would not be alone in thinking that because Read led the team with an inclusivity that had never previously been witnessed in the All Blacks.
He was a leader with time for everyone. He was a captain who wanted to bring down the real and perceived barriers that were preventing the team from being truly united.
Read changed what others couldn’t and to understand his impact, we have to go back to a different time: a period when the All Blacks were riven with internal struggles and quaint ideas about how they should operate.
This story is from the Issue 203 December 2019 - January 2020 edition of NZ Rugby World.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the Issue 203 December 2019 - January 2020 edition of NZ Rugby World.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
The 20 Most Memorable Rugby Acts Of 2020
2020- Most Amazing Rugby Acts
RUGBY ROYALTY
FRANS STEYN’S IMPACT AT LAST YEAR’S WORLD CUP ADDED MORE PRESTIGE TO A DECORATED CAREER THAT ISN’T OVER YET. CRAIG LEWIS FROM SA RUGBY MAGAZINE REPORTS.
WINGING IT FOR LONGER
TYPICALLY POWER WINGS DON'T LAST LONG IN THE ALL BLACKS. BUT CALEB CLARKE AND RIEKO IOANE ARE HOPING TO BUCK THE TREND.
TOUGHEST JOB IN THE WORLD
NZ RUGBY WORLD EDITOR GREGOR PAUL HAS A NEW BOOK OUT CALLED THE CAPTAIN'S RUN. IN IT HE EXPLORES WHAT IT TAKES TO LEAD THE WORLD'S BEST RUGBY TEAM, HOW THE JOB HAS CHANGED AND HOW THE VARIOUS LEADERS HAVE DEALT WITH PRESSURE, FAILURE AND SUCCESS.
WOW FACTOR
SCOTT ROBERTSON IS UNORTHODOX BUT HE'S ALSO BRILLIANT AND WANTS A JOB WITH THE BRITISH & IRISH LIONS.
RUGBY REBORN
COVID BROUGHT ECONOMIC CARNAGE IN 2020 BUT RATHER THAN BEING SEEN AS A WRECKER OF FORTUNES, THE PANDEMIC WAS ACTUALLY A GIANT BLESSING.
BATTLE FOR THE BLEDISLOE
THE UNPRECEDENTED CONDITIONS OF 2020 SAW THE INTERNATIONAL CALENDAR HASTILY REDRAWN AND IN A UNIQUE TWIST FOR THE PROFESSIONAL AGE, THE ALL BLACKS PLAYED FOUR CONSECUTIVE TESTS AGAINST AUSTRALIA.
PACIFIC POWER HOUSE
FIJI HAVE NEVER QUITE BEEN ABLE TO FULFIL THEIR ENORMOUS POTENTIAL. BUT THEY MIGHT NOW FOLLOWING THE APPOINTMENT OF VERN COTTER AS HEAD COACH.
THE PEOPLE'S CHAMPION
ON AND OFF THE FIELD, SPRINGBOKS WING CHESLIN KOLBE CONTINUES TO MAKE AN INSPIRATIONAL IMPACT.
DEFENCE FORCE ONE
THE BLUES WERE A RADICALLY DIFFERENT TEAM IN 2020 AND MUCH OF THAT WAS DUE TO THEIR VASTLY IMPROVED WORK ON DEFENCE.
