faves Jay & Sarah 'FAME ALMOST DESTROYED US'
Woman’s Day Magazine NZ|January 31, 2022
As they introduce their new addition, the high school sweethearts reveal how their family was nearly torn apart
Hayley Barnett
faves Jay & Sarah 'FAME ALMOST DESTROYED US'

When My Kitchen Rules NZ fan favorites Jay Wanakore and Sarah Wanakore-Chase welcomed their fifth child, gorgeous little girl Avaani, five months ago, they say their whānau finally felt complete.

But while it may seem like a fairytale happy ending for the Kiwi reality stars, the couple reveals it hasn't been all smooth sailing since they made their TV debut in 2015.

"After MKR, things became really toxic between us," Jay, 31, admits to Woman's Day: “We got so bad that we were done. Sarah wanted to separate and tried to kick me out a few times."

The Auckland pair spent years successfully building their brand after the show aired, with their very own cookbook, further TV appearances, and a strong social media game, but it was far from fun, with self-confessed workaholic Jay “hustling hard" to carve out a carefully curated niche as a foodie family on a mission to lead healthier lives.

“I was trying to build the dream that I thought we both wanted, but I didn't realize I was compromising our time together," confesses Jay, who is of Waikato and Ngāti Maniapoto descent. “That created a lot of resentment between us. We would go out into the public and put on happy faces, but behind it, all was a lot of stress and unhappiness."

In the background, while Jay was moulding their family into a brand, Sarah was struggling to play along. “I didn't want to be a part of it," the 31-year-old tells. “The image was the priority in his eyes, but I don't like faking who I am and I felt like I was expected to be someone else. Jay had to learn a hard lesson. What he thought was the priority wasn't all that important in the end."

This story is from the January 31, 2022 edition of Woman’s Day Magazine NZ.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the January 31, 2022 edition of Woman’s Day Magazine NZ.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM WOMAN’S DAY MAGAZINE NZView All
JUDGE JAY-JAY
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

JUDGE JAY-JAY

Radio diva Jay-Jay Feeney delivers her verdict on your biggest dilemmas

time-read
2 mins  |
January 06, 2025
MEGAN'S NEW LIFE - 'I WAS STARVING MYSELF'
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

MEGAN'S NEW LIFE - 'I WAS STARVING MYSELF'

After years of negative comments about her weight, the New Plymouth woman is now a plus-size model

time-read
3 mins  |
January 06, 2025
PODCASTS & PARENTHOOD RYAN'S TRUE CALLING
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

PODCASTS & PARENTHOOD RYAN'S TRUE CALLING

Crime investigator Ryan Wolf and wife Ashley welcome baby Dillon to their pack

time-read
3 mins  |
January 06, 2025
CAKE QUEEN KATHERINE - BAKING IS A GOOD WAY TO MAKE FRIENDS!
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

CAKE QUEEN KATHERINE - BAKING IS A GOOD WAY TO MAKE FRIENDS!

A former teacher, cookbook author Katherine Sabbath is now a contestant on Dessert Masters

time-read
1 min  |
January 06, 2025
Celeb chef Amaury's - SWEET SUCCESS
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

Celeb chef Amaury's - SWEET SUCCESS

The MasterChef: Dessert Masters host opens up about his famous fans

time-read
1 min  |
January 06, 2025
Paralympic medallist Anna - 'I'VE PUT MY FAMILY THROUGH HELL'
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

Paralympic medallist Anna - 'I'VE PUT MY FAMILY THROUGH HELL'

The cycling star says she couldn't have won silver in Paris without the support of her loved ones

time-read
4 mins  |
January 06, 2025
MADDY & CHARLOTTE - 'THEY FLAT-OUT LIED!'
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

MADDY & CHARLOTTE - 'THEY FLAT-OUT LIED!'

When a video surfaces of Sydney sisters Maddy and Charlotte Harry showing they'd renovated other houses before their appearance on The Block, their competitors feel betrayed.

time-read
1 min  |
January 06, 2025
SHAYNNA AT 61 'I WON'T GIVE UP!'
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

SHAYNNA AT 61 'I WON'T GIVE UP!'

At 61, The Block Australia judge Shaynna Blaze is busier than ever.

time-read
1 min  |
January 06, 2025
PAST BLOCKHEADS SLAM THE SHOW
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

PAST BLOCKHEADS SLAM THE SHOW

After just quitting The Block citing mental health issues, Jesse, 29, and Paige, 27, haven't held back when it comes to criticising producers for a lack of duty of care - and now Paige claims she has been backed up by several former contestants with similar experiences.

time-read
1 min  |
January 06, 2025
BUILDERS BOYCOTTING THE BLOCK!
Woman’s Day Magazine New Zealand

BUILDERS BOYCOTTING THE BLOCK!

Rogue builders have shared their horror stories from The Block - and they aren't just about bills going unpaid!

time-read
1 min  |
January 06, 2025