Not every general can be Sun Tzu. Some might have benefited from the Chinese strategist's advice, but many military leaders, it seems, never bothered reading him - or more likely never knew he existed. Some great generals never had any formal military training; command was thrust upon them, thanks to their royal blood, their nobility or even their elevation by their peers. The idea of formal training in command and staff work is a relatively modern phenomenon, first emerging in its present form during the mid 19th century. Still, the best generals read about the campaigns of those who came before them.
For instance, the Emperor Napoleon rarely travelled anywhere without a small library, whose titles included Caesar's Gallic Wars, Arrian's The Anabasis Of Alexander [the Great], and other ancient military texts by Thucydides and Xenophon. The idea was that by studying the battles of the past, you would be better prepared to fight those of your own.
Of course, it could be argued that the problems facing Julius Caesar or Alexander the Great were very different from those of later generations of commanders. Still, if even Napoleon recognised the benefits of learning from the past, then the chances were, other generals would profit from them too. While writing 100 Greatest Battles for Osprey Publishing, this link between commanders from previous centuries grew increasingly obvious to its author, Angus Konstam. For example, the tactics used by Caesar at the Siege of Alesia in 52 BCE would have influenced the operations of the Vietminh commander General Giáp at the Siege of Dien Bien Phu in 1954. The only time the adage that history repeats itself is especially true is when lessons gleaned from past battles are used to plan military operations in later centuries.
This story is from the Issue 131 edition of All About History UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the Issue 131 edition of All About History UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
STALIN HAD CONTINUED WEST AFTER BERLIN?
Having used the Allies for his own ends, the Soviet dictator plots to overthrow the rest of Europe
THE GLORIOUS FIRST OF JUNE
ATLANTIC OCEAN, 400 NAUTICAL MILES WEST OF USHANT 28 MAY - 1 JUNE 1794
LIFE AS AS A GODDESS
Jasmine Elmer uncovers the complexity and darker sides of ancient deities and delivers history with soul
TUDOR FASHION TIPS
From farthingales and ruffs to codpieces, ten ways to achieve the styles of the Tudor court
THE FIRST AMERICANS
Discover indigenous life before the colonists landed
THE LAVENDER SCARE
How a national fear of communism led to the American government outing and firing thousands of gay and lesbian workers
STARS BEHIND THE BARS
Ten iconic celebrity mugshots and the stories behind them
The Making of JAPAN
The rise of imperial power and a flourishing of the arts and culture in the Land of the Rising Sun can be traced back to the Asuka period
SIEGE OF TOULON
TOULON, FRENCH REPUBLIC SEPTEMBER-DECEMBER 1793
REDISCOVERING THE FORGOTTEN LIVES OF QUEER MEN
We speak to the editor of a groundbreaking new collection that uncovers what life was like for gay men when homosexuality was illegal in Britain