If you're looking for what's successful, follow box-office rankings. 12th Fail (2023) was a rare movie that was loved by critics and made money too.
Kenneth Turan, film critic for the LA Times, didn't enjoy Titanic when the film was released in 1997. AO Scott of The New York Times dismissed the 2012 blockbuster The Avengers as "grinding, hectic emptiness". Both films have thrilled audiences around the world and made hundreds of millions. Meanwhile, restaurant reviews are often out of sync with a user rating on a delivery app. In the book-publishing world, readers and reviews are routinely at loggerheads. Even critical reviews of runway shows can make or break a popular designer.
So, does it help to listen to the critics? Or do the crowds really know more than a handful of experts? It's tricky territory. But here are some general guidelines.
Watch out for exaggeration.
"With new restaurants, "catchphrases such as 'Must Try' and 'Hidden Gem' used without justification are worrying signs", says Nikhil Merchant, blogger and writer. Other suspicious terms: "Offbeat", "Instagram-worthy". For books, steer clear of "This book that will change your life". Wellread folks rarely use it.
Run an authenticity check.
This story is from the May 11, 2024 edition of Brunch.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the May 11, 2024 edition of Brunch.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Crack the secret open
10 Easter eggs you may have missed in your favourite films. Some broke the fourth wall, some snuck in nods to real people. Some are simply silly
When art blurs borders
Shilpa Gupta's work maps our collective imagination. It confronts the viewer with questions of nationhood and belonging
What could go wrong?
A lot of things, as every chronic worrier knows. But life goes on, whether you worry or not. Here's how to accept it
Where to dine like a king
London has an exciting mix of grand legacy restaurants and newer, sleeker dining places. What do they have in common? Chefs who aim for perfection
Gender no barre
Male ballet dancers are tiptoeing around taboos, training hard, and taking the stage, head held high. Meet four young men taking this leap of faith. See what it means to stand out among women, land a role and own it
The Cat's out of the bag
Five months. Three continents. A 77-city tour. Peter Cat Recording Co. is living every rocker's dream. How did they pull it off?
Back to the daily grind
If you didn't choose the mug life. But why is café coffee always better? From bean to brew, here's how to find the best roast for you
The clock's not watching
Slow down, you crazy child. Hard work and hustling will take you far. But there's no race to win and no deadline on goals
How readers digest
To make a good book great, stir in a tasty treat. These 10 foods are pretty much inseparable from the stories they inhabit
Believe in a higher power
Audi's new luxury EV is the best of form and function. It combines crazy tech, grand interiors and over-the-top features into an SUV that overshadows its rivals