IN EARLY 2020, AS THE PANDEMIC WAS LOOMING, Dr. Anthony Fauci corresponded with a group of scientists about the possibility that the COVID-19 virus escaped from a lab in Wuhan, China. After conference call, the scientists published a paper downplaying the lab-leak theory.
Jim Jordan, a Republican representative from Ohio who began questioning witnesses on Wednesday in the House hearings on the origin of the pandemic, has his own way of weaving those facts into a narrative. It's a story of gross malfeasance, with Fauci as villain.
The best thing about the debate over the origin of COVID-19-or the worst thing, depending on your point of view is that it provides great fodder for constructing narratives. Consider one alternative view of Fauci's actions. Amid the worst public health crisis in a century, perhaps it was wise of him to consult with evolutionary biologists and virologists about the possible causes of the pandemic. And although downplaying the lab-leak idea seems, in hindsight, like bad policy (which Newsweek reported in April 2020), at the time, with the U.S. depending on precious information from Beijing, it might have seemed smart to avoid alienating the Chinese government.
We all tell stories, but when it comes to the origins of COVID-19, the possibilities are particularly rich not just in the House chambers but throughout the debate. Over the past few years, experts seem to have gravitated to one side of the question or the other and dug themselves in.
They can do this because the debate lacks dispositive evidence one way or the other. There is no proof that the virus originated in a lab, and no proof that it emerged as a spillover from nature. What we have instead is a smorgasbord of facts from which to assemble arguments, one way or the other, to suit ourselves.
This story is from the March 31 - April 07, 2023 (Double Issue) edition of Newsweek US.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the March 31 - April 07, 2023 (Double Issue) edition of Newsweek US.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Andrew McCarthy
IN THE 1980S, A GROUP OF ACTORS CALLED THE \"BRAT PACK\" CAME TO define a generation.
Welcomes the World
This summer's Paris Olympics finds a city embracing its role as host to drive innovation, investment and sustainable growth for the benefit of the French nation.
Battle of the Sexless
The Oscars could ditch best actor and actress awards for a gender-neutral category. Not everyone likes the idea
Squid Gains
Lee Jung-jae on moving from the cult Netflix hit to his first Englishspeaking role in Star Wars: The Acolyte
AMERICA'S Greatest Workplaces 2024
COMPANIES THAT CREATE A GREAT WORKPLACE ARE MORE LIKELY TO HAVE ENGAGED workers who care about their jobs.
IT'S ALL ABOUT PRIORITIES
THEY HAPPILY USE THE LABEL \"PRIORITIZERS.\"
'It Has Taken a Devastating Toll'
Financial insecurity is causing a mental health crisis, with nearly two-thirds of Americans saying money matters cause them the most stress
Exhausted No More
Political polarization has led to burned-out Americans, weary of civic discourse. The answer lies not in disengagement but, rather, positive engagement
Reef Rehab
Innovative concrete structures mix with corals to defend the coastline during hurricane season
Biden's European Headache
The right-wing surge in the EU elections could hamper the president's ambitions in Ukraine and play into the hands of his election rival, Donald Trump
