In a searing criticism of the Congress, she said that when the party was in power, amendments to the Constitution were made for personal gains rather than national interest.
"Many (countries) have changed their constitutions, not just amended them, but literally changed the entire feature of their Constitution. But our Constitution has stood the test of time, of course, it yielded itself to very many amendments," she said.
Initiating the debate to mark the 75th year of the Constitution in the Rajya Sabha, the minister said there were four parameters on which the amendments can be gauged to be in public and national interest. "While looking at those amendments, I would like to have a touchstone of four different elements—is the social intent and the social outcome behind many Constitutional amendment genuine; if the economic intent and the economic outcome behind any Constitutional amendment is bonafide and has it helped the society at large; has the process adopted for the amendment itself, and the Constitutional Spirit behind such an amendment," she said.
She then proceeded to argue that from Jawaharlal Nehru to Rajiv Gandhi, the Congress only made amendments to secure the "interests of the family."
The first Constitutional amendment was brought by Nehru to curb freedom of speech in 1951, she said and cited the arrests of actor Balraj Sahni and lyricist and poet Majrooh Sultanpuri to highlight how the freedom of expression was curtailed. "An interim government felt the need to bring the first amendment...The first amendment to curb the freedom of speech, The first Prime Minister deplored press scrutiny of his government," she said.
This story is from the December 17, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times Noida.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 17, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times Noida.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Varanasi concert row: Monali Thakur reacts to sexual harassment claims
Just around 15 days after singer-actor Monali Thakur shut down her show in Varanasi (Uttar Pradesh) over poor management, she has broken her silence on the allegations of sexual harassment levelled against her and her crew by the show organisers.
We Need to Talk About Young Girls' Food Depression
Actor Rakul Preet Singh expresses concern over how a number of young girls are becoming anorexic and bulimic to meet tough beauty standards
Cummins, the pace spearhead
World's Top Bowlers Since Cummins Became Skipper
Agarkar To Brief Selectors Ahead Of BCCI Meet On Sunday
The selection committee will be in full attendance for the knockout rounds of the Vijay Hazare Trophy one-dayers in Vadodara, which start with the pre-quarter finals on Thursday.
Djokovic: At his happy hunting ground, with an old foe in tow
The Serbian has worked with Becker, Agassi and Ivanisevic. In Murray he has access to the mind of a master tactician
Olympic champs Axelsen, An top the field for India Open
Reigning Olympic champions Viktor Axelsen and An Se Young will be among the star attractions at the latest iteration of the Yonex-Sunrise India Open that kicks off in capital's Indira Gandhi Stadium next week.
Indian hockey players bonding with the best in relaunched HIL
Skipper Sumit Walmiki and Australian Tim Brand walked to the dugout, shared a laugh and high-fived after Hyderabad Toofans' practice. Nearby, an awe-struck Amandeep Lakra was listening with rapt attention to Gonzalo Peillat as Germany's drag-flick legend gave the Indian youngster tips to take PCs.
Shooter Tomar Finds Fresh High After Domestic Double
Varun Tomar's dream of representing India at the Paris Olympics was crushed when he lost in the domestic selection trials to pick the final squad.
Neeraj to star in a world javelin event in India
India's two-time Olympic medallist and reigning world champion Neeraj Chopra will be the star attraction in a marquee international javelin tournament at home later this year, the Athletics Federation of India (AFI) said on Tuesday.
Cloud over review of 14-yr-old trade pact with Asean
THE REVIEW HAS STALLED SINCE INDIA'S OFFER OF A UNIFIED DUTY STRUCTURE HAS NOT FOUND FAVOUR AMONG ASEAN MEMBERS