While there are many lenses through which one might view the Supreme Court, the ultimate test of its success must be its legitimacy, its ability to command respect and compliance. By this standard, we must all be troubled by recent trends, now too frequent to be shrugged off as mere aberrations.
In one instance, a judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court (HC) made sharply critical comments about an interim order of the Supreme Court. A five-judge bench of the Supreme Court was promptly constituted by then CJI Chandrachud, and the offending observations expunged. In another case, a judge of the Calcutta HC continued hearing a sensitive political matter after having been explicitly directed by the apex court to desist. In a third example, a Karnataka HC judge, while not addressing the Supreme Court directly, made remarks widely criticised as religiously insensitive and misogynistic.
In each of these cases, the Court has come down with a heavy hand, and self-consciously so. Five judge benches have been constituted to send a clear and unequivocal message. But in all of this, a deeper introspection is eschewed. Why are high court judges—constitutional functionaries themselves—so frequently thought to be disregarding the apex court's writ? Why do even final Supreme Court judgments so often seem like merely another page in the chapter, and not the definitive word they must ideally be understood to be?
This story is from the November 12, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the November 12, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
What The Biden Years Meant For New Delhi
Joe Biden gave India one of its biggest recent diplomatic wins. By being flexible in the formulation around the Ukraine war, he paved the way for the New Delhi Declaration and made the Indian G20 presidency a grand success.
Trump picks Indian-American Harmeet Dhillon as assistant AG
WASHINGTON: US President-elect Donald Trump has nominated Harmeet Dhillon, a Republican leader and lawyer from California who backed the farmers' protests in 2020 and slammed India for allegedly plotting assassinations of Sikhs in North America more recently, as the assistant attorney general in charge of civil rights in the Department of Justice.
Strained Iran-Israel Relations A Matter Of Concern: Jaishankar
The tensions between Israel and Iran are a "source of concern" and India's diplomatic efforts are focused on addressing this issue, external affairs minister S Jaishankar said on Sunday.
Moscow grants asylum to Assad: Russian media
Syria's Bashar Assad and his family have arrived in Russia and have been granted asylum by the Russian authorities, Russian news agencies reported on Sunday, citing a Kremlin source.
How minilateralism is reshaping global order
Notwithstanding United States (US) President-elect Donald Trump's warning to the BRICS nations of 100% tariffs if the grouping created a new currency to challenge the US dollar, the future of the international order remains decisively minilateral.
Deluge of deals to lift i-bank bonuses to record in 2024
India's dealmakers may win record bonuses for 2024, after fetching the decade's highest fee income driven by share sales, mergers and debt funding rounds.
A stall is born
\"Chai/Coffee. Garma-garam poori. Aloo ki subzi. Garam-garam parathe.\" It is all handwritten in black.
SCHOOL DEATH: AUTOPSY REPORT RELEASED, CAUSE STILL UNKNOWN
A week after a 12-year-old boy died after a scuffle with his classmate inside their class in Chinmaya Vidyalaya in Vasant Vihar, police said the preliminary autopsy report has been released but it did not specify the cause of death.
Man killed in E Delhi over suspected affair, accused absconding
A man allegedly stabbed to death a former neighbour in New Ashok Nagar, east Delhi, on Monday night over suspicions of the victim having an extramarital affair with his wife, police said.
‘India can play a key role in rebuilding America... Delhi must take Trump’s win as an opportunity’
Mukesh Aghi is the president and CEO of the US-India Strategic Partnership Forum (USISPF).