The recent controversial hate speech by Justice Shekhar Kumar Yadav of the Allahabad High Court deserves to be deprecated in the strongest terms. He made open and disparaging comments against minorities. He mistook constitutional democracy for conventional democracy, and spoke as if communal majoritarianism is synonymous to democracy. The oath under the third schedule of the Constitution obliges him to uphold the integrity of India and perform his duties "without fear or favour, affection or ill-will" and also "uphold the Constitution and laws".
The text of his speech clearly negates the solemn affirmation in the oath he has taken. Thus, the nation was confronted with a scenario where a judge of a constitutional court discarded the values of the fundamental law in public. That the Chief Justice Sanjeev Khanna acted in time and called for a report on the incident is a matter of solace. Justice Yadav has also been summoned to appear before the collegium of judges at the Supreme Court.
More than an aberration by an individual judge, the incident reflects an unhealthy trend among some judges to lean towards political power centres. For them, personal agenda prevails over their assigned constitutional role. The Congress era also showed a series of such shameless abandonment of judicial constituencies in search of political or other positions. Contemporary India, too, has her bad apples.
This story is from the December 19, 2024 edition of The New Indian Express Kochi.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 19, 2024 edition of The New Indian Express Kochi.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Cinema is my way of addressing social issues
When we are seated in front of theatre screens, diving deep into the world of a film, seldom do we understand the technical effort that goes behind creating the fictional world.
What Sets Rekhachithram Apart Is Its Backdrop
Ahead of its release today, Jofin T Chacko discusses his sophomore directorial Rekhachithram, the challenges of crafting an alternate history narrative, casting choices, and more
Rekindling a Poetic Tradition
TNIE takes a look at how the literary artform of Aksharaslokam is being preserved through cultural groups and Kalolsavam
Creations in distant lands
ASK any middle-class Indian household if they have members of their clan in distant shores and the answer would certainly be in the affirmative.
My Award Is A Recognition For Swimming Itself
In a quick chat with TNIE, ace Malayali swimmer Sajan Prakash, who has been chosen for the Arjuna Award, shares his hope of swimming getting its due in India
Will return to cinema if the work is exciting
VINDUJA Menon shone on the Kalolsavam stage of 1991, bagging what was then the topmost honour – the Kalathilakam.
After New Year revelry, Kochi turns the page to Youth Literature Festival
THE second edition of the Yuvadhara Youth Literature Festival, organised by the DYFI, will commence on Thursday and will continue until January 12.
BFI Adopts New Weight Classes
The Boxing Federation of India (BFI) is conducting the men's national championships here in 10 weight categories, in line with the classification introduced by the breakaway World Boxing. The ongoing event is being held under World Boxing's Technical and Competition Rules.
SA20: Skipper Markram aims a threepeat with Sunrisers Eastern Cape
FRESH from playing a key role in helping South Africa qualify for the third edition of the World Test Championship, Aiden Markram has set his sights on a threepeat with Sunrisers Eastern Cape in the SA20.
AFI's big push: Decentralisation of camps
New-look athletics body's one-of-a-kind policy set to encourage inclusivity & have wider pool of players to pick from