Back in the mid-noughties, Simpson cemented legendary status by orchestrating Carlisle's quickfire rise from the Conference to League One.
And in 2022, 16 years after leaving for Preston, he became a hometown hero all over again, saving the Cumbrians from relegation to the National League before winning an against-all-odds play-off final against big-spending Stockport the following season.
Then, the wheels came off. Carlisle won just seven games in League One last term and were relegated in April having spent three solid months at the foot of the table.
A new ownership group initially backed Simpson, but a slow start saw him sacked just four games into the current season.
"It's been a very tough 2024, and losing my job did hurt," says the former Manchester City winger, who also played for Oxford and Derby before embarking on a 22-year career in coaching and management that includes winning the Under-20 World Cup with England in 2017.
"But I'm not scarred by it, which can happen sometimes.
I remember when I finished at Stockport in 2011. That was such a horrible experience for me I actually questioned whether I ever wanted to get back into football at all.
"I don't feel that wa with Carlisle. I look back and I'm massively proud. That first 15 games when we stayed up was an incredible experience, as big an achievement as anything I've done in my whole career.
"To see the whole of the city and the local area coming back together nothing tops that.
This story is from the October 13, 2024 edition of The Football League Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the October 13, 2024 edition of The Football League Paper.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
RAVENS FLY TO STORMY SUCCESS
ANDY Woodman admitted Bromley's win over Accrington is a game his victorious side 'will never watch back again'.
U'S TAME THE A FAST START
GARETH Ainsworth was dismayed with Shrewsbury's defending as his side were beaten by a rampant Cambridge, in a game which included a goal in the first minute of both halves.
SUPER BLUES' JAY AT DOUBLE
JAY STANSFIELD bagged the plaudits for Birmingham with a brace as they hit back to beat ten-man Barnsley in front of 5,000 travelling fans at Oakwell.
MATT'S ODE TO JOY FOR DETERMINED CHAIRBOYS
Royals in recovery with boss departed
IT JUST EXPLODED OUT OF NOWHERE - IT WAS WILD!
SHEFFIELD United v West Brom? For fans of a certain vintage, it's a fixture that can only conjure one memory.
ROHL RAGES WITH HIS SLOPPY OWLS
DANNY Rohl ripped into his Sheffield Wednesday side after they were held at home by Preston.
ACE KEEPER KAMINSKI IS THE BIG DIFFERENCE
LUKE Williams insisted that his Swansea City side could well have left with all three points after being denied victory by home keeper Thomas Kaminski.
Kolli is Marti's new Ray of sunshine
PROUD QPR boss Marti Cifuentes is hoping Rayan Kolli's maiden senior goals prove to be \"the first of many\" after the youngster played a starring role in the victory over Norwich.
FIRST WIN FOR FRANK AS LIONS ARE TAMED
COVENTRY head coach Frank Lampard felt his players took the game by the scruff of the neck after half-time the Sky Blues.
EUSTACE SALUTES BATTLING ROVERS
But a lot to ponder for Selles