CINDY BETHEL WAS 6 when her babysitter’s neighbor started molesting her. Worried what else would happen if she told her parents, she confided in her stuffed panda instead. Sometimes she acted out the abuse with Barbie and Ken dolls. A few years later, the same teen neighbor raped her on a woodpile outside his house. She didn’t tell anyone about the assault until long after she moved away from her Ohio hometown.
Even if she had spoken out, investigators may have struggled to get her full story. Young children often say what they think adults want to hear, and kids are easily influenced by an interviewer’s word choice, tone, and body language all of which can lead them to provide false information. Children’s testimony helped condemn innocent people during the Salem witch trials. And in the 1980s, panic about alleged satanic abuse at daycare centers spread when social workers nudged kids to accuse their caregivers. A series of studies in the 1990s, led by a psychologist at Cornell University, found that prolonged suggestive questioning caused more than half of 4- to 6- year-olds to recall details about life experiences that had never occurred.
Even well-trained interviewers make mistakes, like forgetting to ask open-ended questions, says Zoe Klemfuss, an assistant professor at the University of California, Irvine, who studies children’s memory and forensic interviews. “You’re cognitively having to do so many things at once, while being sympathetic to the child, while getting legally relevant information,” she says. The stakes are high: Tens of thousands of kids testify at criminal trials every year.
This story is from the May/June 2020 edition of Mother Jones.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the May/June 2020 edition of Mother Jones.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
HOG WILD
The scandalous reason meat prices have skyrocketed
ALL WALKS
Limiting cars in cities can help disabled people, too.
REMIGRATION
How Trumpism is following the far right in Europe toward mass expulsion of immigrants
SETTLING THE SCORE
A pop psychology book is considered the definitive trauma text. But what if it's leading survivors down the wrong path?
Positive Spin
People with e-bikes drive less, pollute less, parkinglots-and that's only part of why cities and states are embracing them with gusto.
Cradle and All
The devastating cost of Utah's thriving adoption industry
THE BILLIONAIRE WHO NEARLY BROKE NEWPORT
TRUMP MEGADONOR STEPHEN SCHWARZMAN'S EXTREME MANSION MAKEOVER IS DRIVING HIS NEIGHBORS NUTS.
THE SECRET PLAN TO STRIKE DOWN US GUN LAWS
AND THE COP-TURNED-PASTOR AT THE CENTER OF IT ALL
GOOD NIGHT AND GOOD LUCK
Election Day inside a bustling broadcast newsroom that no longer exists
MASTER OF DISASTER
Trump won’t confront the climate crisis. He’ll feast off it.